Files
dify/api/services/dify_builder/dify_port.py
T
Charles YaoandClaude Opus 5 d2e204f133 fix(dify-builder): stop the test step deadlocking and losing its outcome
Two defects, both introduced by the streaming switch in 3838db8aa7, which
together livelocked every Builder test run.

1. Self-deadlock. run_draft executes inside the Celery task
   dify_builder_advance_task.advance_session. Streaming mode does not run
   the workflow in place: it enqueues workflow_based_app_execution_task
   via delay() on first subscribe (app_generate_service.py:322-324) and
   returns a Redis subscription. The advance task then blocked on events
   from a task needing the worker slot the advance task was holding.
   Observed live: advance_session "succeeded in 300.59s" (the idle
   timeout) four times over, while each workflow_run finished in under 2s.
   Deadlocks every time at worker concurrency 1, and as soon as N test
   runs are in flight at concurrency N.

2. Lost outcome. Blocking mode returns a Mapping
   {"task_id", "workflow_run_id", "data"}, but the rewrite consumed the
   response with `for chunk in response`, which walks a dict's KEYS as
   strings. Probed against the real service: 3 chunks, 0 run-id matches,
   0 terminal matches. So every run was recorded status="running" with an
   empty dify_run_id, and the "running" branch bounced the user back to
   build.execution -- forever. The pre-3838db8aa7 code read
   response["data"] directly; the rewrite dropped that path.

Blocking mode restored, Mapping responses handled, and the shared tail
factored into _finish_run so the two paths cannot disagree about an
outcome. The stream-consumption path is kept and still tested, for a
future consumer that is NOT a worker -- which is what live per-node
streaming to the frontend will require.

Verified end to end on a local stack: one test run, status succeeded with
a real run id, advance_session 0.04-31.8s, and the session reaching
build.review instead of looping.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-09-20 22:10:28 -07:00

463 lines
21 KiB
Python

"""The real ``DifyPort`` adapter -- direct in-process calls into Dify's own services.
Port of dify-enterprise/server/pkg/enterprise/data/dify_builder_dify.go, minus the
token-forwarding (the P1 port plan's Global Constraints / ADR drop
``ForwardAuth`` entirely -- see ``core.dify_builder.ports.DifyPort``).
``WorkflowServiceDifyPort`` wires the pure P1 domain (``core.dify_builder``)
and the pure Task 1-3 helpers in this package (``graph_ops``, ``run_mapping``,
``identity``) to ``WorkflowService`` / ``AppGenerateService`` / the node-
execution repository. It satisfies ``DifyPort`` structurally (the Protocol is
``@runtime_checkable``) -- there is no explicit inheritance.
Each method opens its own ``Session`` via
``sessionmaker(bind=db.engine, expire_on_commit=False)`` and resolves
account/app through the Task 3 helpers. The OSS gotchas baked in here (see
the P2 plan's Global Constraints):
- ``sync_draft_workflow`` has no server-side patch primitive -- ``apply_repair``
reads the whole draft graph, mutates it client-side via
``graph_ops.apply_set_node_config``, and writes the whole mutated graph
back with ``graph_only=True``/``sync_agent_bindings=False`` so only the
graph changes, nothing else. A ``WorkflowHashNotEqualError`` (the draft
changed since it was read) is re-mapped to the domain ``HashMismatchError``.
- ``run_draft`` invokes ``AppGenerateService.generate`` with
``invoke_from=InvokeFrom.DEBUGGER`` (runs the *draft*, not the published
workflow) and ``streaming=True``, so ``on_event`` fires while the run is
still going instead of replaying finished rows afterwards. Streaming makes
``AppGenerateService`` hand the execution to the
``workflow_based_app_execution`` Celery queue and hand *us* a Redis-backed
event stream; the Builder's own task runs on the separate ``dify_builder``
queue, so the two never contend for the same worker slots. If the stream
ends WITHOUT a terminal frame (idle timeout, dead publishing worker), the
outcome is recovered from the workflow-run row rather than synthesised as a
failure -- reporting a run that actually succeeded as failed would feed the
repair loop a lie.
- ``publish`` MUST update ``app.workflow_id`` in the same transaction as
``publish_workflow``: ``publish_workflow`` only creates the new published
``Workflow`` row: it does not repoint the app at it. Skipping that update
makes publish a silent no-op. The agent-retirement tail
(``WorkflowAgentRetirementService.retire_unowned`` /
``enqueue_agent_resource_collection``) is intentionally skipped -- it only
matters for Agent-node workflows and is not part of this port's contract.
"""
from collections.abc import Callable, Mapping
from typing import Any
from sqlalchemy.orm import Session, sessionmaker
from core.app.entities.app_invoke_entities import InvokeFrom
from core.dify_builder.changes import describe_changed_nodes
from core.dify_builder.contract import CanvasEvent
from core.dify_builder.models import (
Actor,
ApplyResult,
Graph,
Inputs,
MutationIntent,
NodeEvent,
NodeOutput,
Run,
)
from extensions.ext_database import db
from graphon.enums import BuiltinNodeTypes
from libs.datetime_utils import naive_utc_now
from models.account import Account
from models.model import App
from models.workflow import Workflow
from repositories.factory import DifyAPIRepositoryFactory
from services.app_generate_service import AppGenerateService
from services.dify_builder import graph_ops
from services.dify_builder.errors import HashMismatchError, WorkflowNotInitializedError
from services.dify_builder.identity import load_app, resolve_account
from services.dify_builder.revision import execution_revision
from services.dify_builder.run_mapping import (
is_unfinished_run_status,
map_run_result,
map_unknown_run_outcome,
node_event_from_stream_chunk,
run_id_from_stream_chunk,
run_result_data_from_run_row,
run_result_data_from_terminal_chunk,
stream_chunk_as_mapping,
)
from services.errors.app import WorkflowHashNotEqualError
from services.workflow_draft_sync_service import notify_workflow_draft_changed
from services.workflow_service import WorkflowService
__all__ = ["WorkflowServiceDifyPort"]
_CREATE_NODE_CANVAS_EVENTS: dict[str, CanvasEvent] = {
BuiltinNodeTypes.START: CanvasEvent.ADD_START_NODE,
BuiltinNodeTypes.KNOWLEDGE_RETRIEVAL: CanvasEvent.ADD_KNOWLEDGE_NODE,
BuiltinNodeTypes.LLM: CanvasEvent.ADD_LLM_NODE,
BuiltinNodeTypes.END: CanvasEvent.ADD_OUTPUT_NODE,
}
def _canvas_event_for_intent(intent: MutationIntent) -> CanvasEvent:
"""Map an applied ``MutationIntent`` to the canvas event that narrates it
(spec Sec 6). ``create_node`` dispatches by ``node_type`` to the matching
``add_*_node`` event; ``set_node_config`` (Fix's only verb today) maps to
``apply_error_fix``; every other verb (``delete_node``/``connect``/
``insert_between``) and any unmapped ``node_type`` default to the
generic ``apply_edit_plan`` batch-mutation event.
"""
if intent.op == "create_node":
return _CREATE_NODE_CANVAS_EVENTS.get(intent.args.get("node_type", ""), CanvasEvent.APPLY_EDIT_PLAN)
if intent.op == "set_node_config":
return CanvasEvent.APPLY_ERROR_FIX
return CanvasEvent.APPLY_EDIT_PLAN
def _canvas_payload(intent: MutationIntent, changed: list[str]) -> dict[str, Any]:
"""Build the ``{"event": ..., "node_id"?/"edge"?}`` dict passed to ``on_canvas``."""
payload: dict[str, Any] = {"event": str(_canvas_event_for_intent(intent))}
if intent.op == "connect":
payload["edge"] = {"source": intent.args.get("from_node"), "target": intent.args.get("to_node")}
elif intent.op == "delete_node":
payload["node_id"] = intent.args.get("node_id")
else: # create_node | insert_between | set_node_config
payload["node_id"] = changed[0] if changed else None
return payload
def _session_factory() -> sessionmaker[Session]:
"""One session per adapter call -- never shared/held across calls."""
return sessionmaker(bind=db.engine, expire_on_commit=False)
def _unwrap_status(status: Any) -> Any:
"""Unwrap a ``graphon`` ``StrEnum``'s ``.value`` if present, else pass through.
Mirrors ``run_mapping._status_value`` locally so this module doesn't reach
into another module's private helper.
"""
return getattr(status, "value", status)
def _load_draft_workflow_or_raise(app: App, *, session: Session) -> Workflow:
workflow = WorkflowService().get_draft_workflow(app, session=session)
if workflow is None:
raise WorkflowNotInitializedError(f"app has no draft workflow: {app.id}")
return workflow
def _sync_graph_only(
app: App,
graph: Graph,
workflow: Workflow,
unique_hash: str,
account: Account,
session: Session,
app_id: str,
) -> Workflow:
"""Write ``graph`` back to the draft via the graph-only sync both
``apply_repair`` and ``restore_graph`` use (no server-side patch
primitive -- see the module docstring). Remaps
``WorkflowHashNotEqualError`` (the draft changed since it was read) to
the domain ``HashMismatchError``."""
try:
return WorkflowService().sync_draft_workflow(
app_model=app,
graph=graph,
features=dict(workflow.features_dict),
unique_hash=unique_hash,
account=account,
environment_variables=[],
conversation_variables=workflow.conversation_variables,
session=session,
graph_only=True,
sync_agent_bindings=False,
commit=True,
preserve_environment_variables=True,
)
except WorkflowHashNotEqualError as exc:
raise HashMismatchError(f"draft workflow changed since read: {app_id}") from exc
class WorkflowServiceDifyPort:
"""``DifyPort`` implementation backed directly by Dify's own services."""
def read_graph(self, app_id: str, actor: Actor) -> tuple[Graph, str]:
with _session_factory()() as session:
app = load_app(session, app_id, actor)
workflow = _load_draft_workflow_or_raise(app, session=session)
return dict(workflow.graph_dict), execution_revision(workflow)
def node_outputs(self, app_id: str, actor: Actor, run_id: str) -> list[NodeOutput]:
with _session_factory()() as session:
app = load_app(session, app_id, actor)
tenant_id = app.tenant_id
node_execs = DifyAPIRepositoryFactory.create_api_workflow_node_execution_repository(
sessionmaker(bind=db.engine)
).get_executions_by_workflow_run(tenant_id, app_id, run_id)
return [
NodeOutput(
node_id=node_exec.node_id,
title=node_exec.title,
status=_unwrap_status(node_exec.status),
error=node_exec.error or "",
inputs=node_exec.inputs_dict or {},
outputs=node_exec.outputs_dict or {},
)
for node_exec in node_execs
]
def apply_repair(
self,
app_id: str,
actor: Actor,
intents: list[MutationIntent],
on_canvas: Callable[[dict], None] | None = None,
*,
expected_revision: str,
) -> ApplyResult:
with _session_factory()() as session:
account = resolve_account(session, actor)
app = load_app(session, app_id, actor)
workflow = _load_draft_workflow_or_raise(app, session=session)
# Lock AND refresh before inspecting the graph: this Session may
# already contain an older Workflow in its identity map. Keep the
# execution check and mutation in the same short transaction.
session.refresh(workflow, with_for_update=True)
revision = execution_revision(workflow)
if revision != expected_revision:
raise HashMismatchError(f"workflow execution configuration changed: {app_id}")
before_graph: Graph = dict(workflow.graph_dict)
graph: Graph = before_graph
unique_hash = workflow.unique_hash
# Idempotent re-entry (interrupted-step Retry): a re-applied fix.apply
# re-sends the same intents against an already-mutated draft. Drop
# create_node for an id already present and connect for an edge already
# present so the re-apply is a clean no-op. Uses the ORIGINAL draft graph
# (before_graph) as the reference, so an in-batch duplicate of a NEW id
# still reaches graph_ops and raises (validation preserved).
#
# Mirror handlers_build.py's M2 guard: ids targeted by a delete_node in
# THIS SAME batch must not count as "already present" for the filter
# above. A from-scratch build sends delete_node(placeholder_start) +
# create_node(same id) in one batch (recreating the id the placeholder
# occupied); without this exclusion the create_node would be dropped as
# already-present while the delete_node still runs, deleting the node
# with no re-create.
_deleted_ids = {i.args.get("node_id") for i in intents if i.op == "delete_node"}
_present_node_ids = {n.get("id") for n in before_graph.get("nodes", [])} - _deleted_ids
_present_edges = {
(e.get("source"), e.get("target"))
for e in before_graph.get("edges", [])
if e.get("source") not in _deleted_ids and e.get("target") not in _deleted_ids
}
def _already_present(intent: MutationIntent) -> bool:
if intent.op == "create_node":
return intent.args.get("node_id") in _present_node_ids
if intent.op == "connect":
return (intent.args.get("from_node"), intent.args.get("to_node")) in _present_edges
return False
intents = [intent for intent in intents if not _already_present(intent)]
changed_nodes: list[str] = []
for intent in intents:
apply_fn = graph_ops.APPLY_FNS.get(intent.op)
if apply_fn is None:
continue
graph_ops.validate_intent_args(intent)
graph, changed = apply_fn(graph, **intent.args)
changed_nodes.extend(changed)
if on_canvas is not None:
on_canvas(_canvas_payload(intent, changed))
if not changed_nodes:
return ApplyResult(
changed_nodes=[],
new_hash=revision,
changes=[],
scope="",
structure_fingerprint=graph_ops.structural_fingerprint(before_graph),
)
changes, scope = graph_ops.diff_graphs(before_graph, graph)
updated = _sync_graph_only(app, graph, workflow, unique_hash, account, session, app_id)
notify_workflow_draft_changed(updated, previous_graph=before_graph)
return ApplyResult(
changed_nodes=changed_nodes,
nodes=describe_changed_nodes(changed_nodes, before_graph, graph),
new_hash=execution_revision(updated),
changes=changes,
scope=scope,
structure_fingerprint=graph_ops.structural_fingerprint(graph),
)
def structural_fingerprint(self, graph: Graph) -> str:
return graph_ops.structural_fingerprint(graph)
def graph_node_ids(self, graph: Graph) -> list[str]:
return graph_ops.node_ids(graph)
def restore_graph(self, app_id: str, actor: Actor, graph: Graph, *, expected_revision: str) -> str:
"""Restore the draft to a prior snapshot graph (Slice 4 revert): write
the whole graph back via the same graph-only sync apply_repair uses.
Returns the new execution revision. Raises HashMismatchError if the
execution configuration changed since the caller read it."""
with _session_factory()() as session:
account = resolve_account(session, actor)
app = load_app(session, app_id, actor)
workflow = _load_draft_workflow_or_raise(app, session=session)
session.refresh(workflow, with_for_update=True)
if execution_revision(workflow) != expected_revision:
raise HashMismatchError(f"workflow execution configuration changed: {app_id}")
updated = _sync_graph_only(app, graph, workflow, workflow.unique_hash, account, session, app_id)
notify_workflow_draft_changed(updated)
return execution_revision(updated)
def run_draft(self, app_id: str, actor: Actor, inputs: Inputs, on_event: Callable[[NodeEvent], None]) -> Run:
with _session_factory()() as session:
account = resolve_account(session, actor)
app = load_app(session, app_id, actor)
tenant_id = app.tenant_id
# MUST stay blocking. ``run_draft`` executes inside the Celery task
# ``dify_builder_advance_task.advance_session``, and streaming mode
# does NOT run the workflow here: it enqueues
# ``workflow_based_app_execution_task.delay(...)`` on first subscribe
# (services/app_generate_service.py:322-324) and hands back a Redis
# subscription. This task would then block on events from a task that
# needs the very worker slot this task is holding -- a self-deadlock.
# Observed live: advance_session "succeeded in 300.59s" (the idle
# timeout) four times running, while each workflow_run itself
# finished in under 2s. It deadlocks every time at worker
# concurrency 1, and as soon as N test runs are in flight at
# concurrency N.
#
# Blocking mode runs the workflow in-process
# (``WorkflowAppGenerator().generate(..., streaming=False)``) and
# returns a dict, so there is no second task to wait for.
response = AppGenerateService.generate(
app_model=app,
user=account,
args={"inputs": inputs},
invoke_from=InvokeFrom.DEBUGGER,
session=session,
streaming=False,
)
final: dict[str, Any] = {}
stream_run_id = ""
# Blocking mode returns a MAPPING ({"task_id", "workflow_run_id",
# "data"}), not a stream. Iterating it would walk its KEYS as strings --
# which is exactly what happened after the streaming rewrite: no run id
# and no terminal frame were ever found, every test run was recorded
# status="running" with an empty dify_run_id, and the Builder bounced the
# user back to build.execution forever. Handle both shapes so the stream
# path stays correct if it is ever reinstated behind a non-worker consumer.
if isinstance(response, Mapping):
final = dict(response.get("data") or {})
if not final.get("id"):
final["id"] = str(response.get("workflow_run_id") or "")
return self._finish_run(tenant_id, app_id, final, stream_run_id="")
try:
for chunk in response:
# Streaming yields SSE-formatted strings ("data: {...}" events
# and "event: ping" keep-alives), not dicts.
payload = stream_chunk_as_mapping(chunk)
if payload is None:
continue
# Every non-ping frame stamps the run id, so it is known long
# before the terminal frame -- which may never arrive.
stream_run_id = stream_run_id or run_id_from_stream_chunk(payload)
node_event = node_event_from_stream_chunk(payload)
if node_event is not None:
on_event(node_event)
continue
terminal = run_result_data_from_terminal_chunk(payload)
if terminal is not None:
final = terminal
finally:
# In streaming mode ``_run_with_guardrails`` does NOT release the
# app's rate-limit slot; only closing the generator does. Normal
# exhaustion self-closes, so this only matters when ``on_event``
# raises -- but a leaked slot blocks every later test run.
close = getattr(response, "close", None)
if callable(close):
close()
return self._finish_run(tenant_id, app_id, final, stream_run_id)
def _finish_run(self, tenant_id: str, app_id: str, final: dict[str, Any], stream_run_id: str) -> Run:
"""Turn the run's terminal data into a ``Run``. Shared by the blocking
and streaming paths so they can never disagree about the outcome."""
run_id = str(final.get("id") or stream_run_id or "")
# The terminal frame carries status, not per-node outputs:
# ``map_run_result`` still needs the node-execution rows.
node_execs = (
DifyAPIRepositoryFactory.create_api_workflow_node_execution_repository(
sessionmaker(bind=db.engine)
).get_executions_by_workflow_run(tenant_id, app_id, run_id)
if run_id
else []
)
if final:
return map_run_result(final, node_execs)
# No terminal data -- a consumed stream ended without its terminal frame
# (idle timeout, or the publishing worker died). The database is now the
# authority on how the run went; synthesising "failed" here would report
# a run that may well have SUCCEEDED as a failed build and feed the
# repair loop a lie.
return self._run_result_without_terminal_frame(tenant_id, app_id, run_id, node_execs)
@staticmethod
def _run_result_without_terminal_frame(tenant_id: str, app_id: str, run_id: str, node_execs: list[Any]) -> Run:
"""Recover a truncated stream's outcome from the workflow-run row."""
run_row = (
DifyAPIRepositoryFactory.create_api_workflow_run_repository(
sessionmaker(bind=db.engine)
).get_workflow_run_by_id(tenant_id=tenant_id, app_id=app_id, run_id=run_id)
if run_id
else None
)
if run_row is None:
# No id, or no row: nothing can say how this went.
return map_unknown_run_outcome({"id": run_id}, node_execs)
recovered = run_result_data_from_run_row(run_row)
if is_unfinished_run_status(recovered["status"]):
# The row says the run is still going, so its outcome is genuinely
# unknown rather than bad.
return map_unknown_run_outcome(recovered, node_execs)
return map_run_result(recovered, node_execs)
def publish(self, app_id: str, actor: Actor) -> None:
with _session_factory()() as session:
account = resolve_account(session, actor)
app = load_app(session, app_id, actor)
workflow = WorkflowService().publish_workflow(
session=session,
app_model=app,
account=account,
)
app_in_session = session.get(App, app_id)
assert app_in_session is not None, f"app disappeared mid-transaction: {app_id}"
app_in_session.workflow_id = workflow.id
app_in_session.updated_by = account.id
app_in_session.updated_at = naive_utc_now()
session.commit()