Files
dify/api/core/dify_builder/contract.py
T
Charles YaoandClaude Opus 5 aa2b4fe4ab feat(dify-builder): name apps from their prompt, and turn gate actions into card options
Two App Builder spec changes that share the Builder session contract.

Naming (spec N1-N3): an app created from the homepage prompt is no longer named
by the user. core/dify_builder/naming.py cuts the prompt's opening clause at
create time -- instant and infallible, since it runs inside POST /apps -- and
CreateAppPayload.name becomes optional alongside a new prompt field. The Builder
then refines that name once during goal analysis, where a model and the detected
reply language are already in hand, so the judgement calls that are
English-shaped in pure Python (dropping an imperative lead-in, spotting a
contentless prompt) work in any language. Plan approval freezes the name.

Card options: SessionView gains a Decision carrying the gate's choice as options
inside the card plus a fixed confirm/cancel pair, replacing a button row whose
shape changed at every state. Option ids are the old action ids untouched, so
resolve_action_kind and the per-state legality check are unchanged, and
SessionView.actions keeps being populated -- the deployed web client goes on
working until it reads decision instead.

The regenerated console OpenAPI doc also picks up ErrorCard.diagnostics, missed
when cc9ca8b1dd landed.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-09-17 17:55:38 -07:00

935 lines
25 KiB
Python

"""Dify Builder FE<->backend interaction contract.
New for the Build/Edit slice (spec: ``docs/superpowers/specs/
2026-08-21-dify-builder-full-flow-contract-design.md``, §2 enums, §6
canvas events, §7 state machines). These enums freeze the wire vocabulary
shared by all entry modes (Fix, Build, Edit) — canned agent today, a future
ProAgent tomorrow, same shapes (§ Global Constraints: "canned-agnostic").
All members are ``StrEnum`` so ``dataclasses.asdict``/``json.dumps`` emit the
snake_case wire value directly; the member name is just the UPPER_SNAKE of
that value.
"""
from dataclasses import asdict, dataclass, field
from enum import StrEnum
from typing import Any, ClassVar, Literal
from core.dify_builder.models import ChangedNode, ConversationItem, EntryMode
class Phase(StrEnum):
"""Coarse UX phase shown in the panel header (spec §2)."""
UNDERSTAND = "understand"
CLARIFY = "clarify"
RESOURCES = "resources"
PLAN = "plan"
MODIFY = "modify"
TEST = "test"
REVIEW = "review"
PUBLISH = "publish"
COMPLETE = "complete"
class RunStatus(StrEnum):
"""Widened run-status vocabulary (spec §2).
``processing`` => ``canvas_read_only = true`` (WORKING).
``waiting_*``/``paused`` => editable (WAITING).
``complete``/``failed`` => terminal.
"""
PROCESSING = "processing"
WAITING_INPUT = "waiting_input"
WAITING_CONFIRMATION = "waiting_confirmation"
PAUSED = "paused"
FAILED = "failed"
COMPLETE = "complete"
class ActionKind(StrEnum):
"""Action button styling / semantics (spec §2, §5).
``automatic`` actions are not buttons — the client must not render
them; the server auto-advances. They exist in the stream only so the
FE can show "auto-continuing...".
"""
PRIMARY = "primary"
SECONDARY = "secondary"
DESTRUCTIVE = "destructive"
AUTOMATIC = "automatic"
class CardKind(StrEnum):
"""The conversation-item/card vocabulary (spec §4)."""
USER = "user"
DECISION = "decision"
NOTICE = "notice"
RUN_CONTEXT = "run_context"
PREFLIGHT_CONTEXT = "preflight_context"
ASSISTANT_TURN = "assistant_turn"
PLAN = "plan"
FORM = "form"
CHALLENGE = "challenge"
RESOURCE_SELECT = "resource_select"
CHECKPOINT = "checkpoint"
CHANGE_SET = "change_set"
TEST_RESULT = "test_result"
ERROR = "error"
SUMMARY = "summary"
PUBLISH = "publish"
BUILD_LEARNING = "build_learning"
class CanvasEvent(StrEnum):
"""Granular canvas-mutation signals (spec §6).
Exactly 22 members, snake_cased from the mock's ``DifyBuilderCanvasEvent``
union. Presentation of committed backend state: replaying these from a
snapshot must reconstruct the same canvas.
"""
RESET_BUILD_CANVAS = "reset_build_canvas"
ADD_START_NODE = "add_start_node"
ADD_KNOWLEDGE_NODE = "add_knowledge_node"
ADD_LLM_NODE = "add_llm_node"
ADD_OUTPUT_NODE = "add_output_node"
FOCUS_WORKFLOW = "focus_workflow"
HIGHLIGHT_EDIT_TARGET = "highlight_edit_target"
APPLY_EDIT_PLAN = "apply_edit_plan"
START_TEST_RUN = "start_test_run"
MARK_TEST_ERROR = "mark_test_error"
FOCUS_ERROR_NODE = "focus_error_node"
FOCUS_CHECKLIST_NODE = "focus_checklist_node"
CREATE_CHECKPOINT = "create_checkpoint"
APPLY_ERROR_FIX = "apply_error_fix"
MARK_REPAIR_APPLIED = "mark_repair_applied"
APPLY_PREFLIGHT_FIX = "apply_preflight_fix"
START_RETEST = "start_retest"
MARK_TEST_SUCCESS = "mark_test_success"
MARK_REVIEW_READY = "mark_review_ready"
REVERT_CHECKPOINT = "revert_checkpoint"
CANCEL_PUBLISH = "cancel_publish"
PUBLISH_WORKFLOW = "publish_workflow"
class ConflictPolicy(StrEnum):
"""Resource-conflict handling in Build (spec §2)."""
AUDITED = "audited"
ASK = "ask"
class SkillLearningPolicy(StrEnum):
"""Governance tail (spec §2). Deferred — contract-only for now."""
ASK = "ask"
AUTOMATIC = "automatic"
DISABLED = "disabled"
class RecoveryClass(StrEnum):
"""How the draft drifted from what the dify_builder last knew, when a session
is reopened after a hand-edit (spec §8 / C-1)."""
UNCHANGED = "unchanged"
CONFIG_ONLY = "config_only"
STRUCTURAL_COMPATIBLE = "structural_compatible"
STRUCTURAL_INVALIDATING = "structural_invalidating"
class BuilderErrorCode(StrEnum):
"""Stable HTTP error codes returned by the Builder console routes."""
BAD_REQUEST = "bad_request"
NOT_FOUND = "not_found"
CONFLICT = "conflict"
SESSION_BUSY = "session_busy"
FEATURE_UNAVAILABLE = "feature_unavailable"
MODEL_UNAVAILABLE = "model_unavailable"
@dataclass
class Action:
"""A UI action the FE renders (spec §5).
DISTINCT from ``core.dify_builder.models.Action`` (the submit DTO
the FE POSTs back) -- this one is what the server *sends* describing a
renderable button.
"""
id: str
label: str
kind: ActionKind
next_state: str | None = None
canvas_event: str | None = None
# The only two buttons an interactive card shows; every real choice is an option
# inside it. One interaction shape at every gate, not one per state.
CONFIRM_ACTION_ID = "confirm"
CANCEL_ACTION_ID = "cancel"
@dataclass
class OptionInput:
"""Free text an option reveals once selected ("Something else", "Reject with a reason").
Bounds are declared for the client to enforce; see ``Decision`` for why the
server does not reject on them yet.
"""
placeholder: str = ""
min_length: int = 0
max_length: int = 100
required: bool = True
@dataclass
class CardOption:
"""One answer a gate offers, inside the card instead of as a button.
``id`` is the former standalone action id, unchanged, so an option resolves
to exactly the handler kind its button used to.
"""
id: str
label: str
# The second line under an option. Empty for now: the per-state action table
# carries labels only, and writing the copy here is a product decision.
description: str = ""
# Shown as a DEFAULT badge. Advisory only -- these gates have side effects,
# so declining to choose must never apply anything.
is_default: bool = False
tone: str = "neutral" # neutral | destructive
input: OptionInput | None = None
next_state: str | None = None
canvas_event: str | None = None
@dataclass
class Decision:
"""What the current gate asks: card options plus the fixed button pair.
Replaces the per-state action bar. The client renders ``options`` in the
active card, shows only ``confirm`` and ``cancel``, and on confirm posts
``confirm`` with ``{"option_id": ..., "free_text": ...}``. ``cancel`` is
presentational -- it dismisses without posting and the gate stays open.
While ``SessionView.actions`` is still populated, the server accepts the old
per-action ids too and does not enforce ``OptionInput`` bounds, so a client
posting a bare action id keeps working. Enforcement moves server-side when
``actions`` goes.
"""
options: list[CardOption] = field(default_factory=list)
confirm: Action | None = None
cancel: Action | None = None
default_option_id: str = ""
@dataclass
class CheckpointRef:
"""Active restore point on the SessionView (spec §8)."""
checkpoint_id: str
label: str
created_at: str
@dataclass
class RecoveryRef:
"""Draft-drift recovery offer on the SessionView (spec §8 / C-1)."""
recovery_class: str
can_continue: bool
can_restart: bool
message: str
@dataclass
class BuilderError:
"""Error body returned before an SSE response starts, or by a JSON route.
``message`` and ``recoverable`` are optional extension fields. Current
responses only require the stable ``code`` field.
"""
code: BuilderErrorCode
message: str | None = None
recoverable: bool | None = None
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Card sub-types (spec §4.3). Plain dataclasses -- no ``kind`` discriminant,
# they nest inside a card's fields rather than standing alone in the
# conversation.
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
@dataclass
class FormField:
"""One field of a ``form`` card, including Start-node input constraints."""
key: str
label: str
type: str
options: list[str] = field(default_factory=list)
required: bool = False
default: str | int | float | bool | None = None
max_length: int | None = field(default=None, metadata={"minimum": 1})
allowed_file_types: list[str] = field(default_factory=list)
allowed_file_extensions: list[str] = field(default_factory=list)
allowed_file_upload_methods: list[str] = field(default_factory=list)
placeholder: str | None = None
hint: str | None = None
unit: str | None = None
json_schema: str | dict[str, Any] | None = None
number_limits: int | None = field(default=None, metadata={"minimum": 1})
@dataclass
class ResourceOption:
"""One recommended resource in a ``resource_select`` card.
``kind`` in knowledge|plugin|model|credential; ``readiness`` in
ready|missing_config|missing_plugin|placeholder|waiting_setup.
Credentials are referenced by name only -- never a secret.
"""
id: str
label: str
meta: str
kind: str
readiness: str
@dataclass
class SessionModel:
"""The LLM chosen for this session, echoed for the FE model picker.
Empty on the wire (``model: null``) means the session uses the tenant default.
"""
provider: str
name: str
mode: str = ""
completion_params: dict[str, Any] = field(default_factory=dict)
@dataclass
class AppRevision:
"""Shared draft-workflow revision associated with a private session.
``observed`` is the revision last incorporated by the Builder engine;
``current`` is read from the app draft when this SessionView is built.
A mismatch tells the client to refresh/rebase before submitting a
workflow-dependent action.
"""
observed: str
current: str
conflicted: bool
@dataclass
class ActiveInteraction:
"""The one persisted card that may accept input at the current version.
Historical cards remain renderable, but the client must only enable this
card. ``valid_at_version`` is an explicit fence in addition to the normal
action ``base_version`` check.
"""
action_id: str
card: ConversationItem
valid_at_version: int
@dataclass
class ConversationPage:
"""A group-safe page of durable conversation items.
``limit`` at the HTTP boundary counts rendered conversation groups rather
than raw rows, so a card bundle is never split from its assistant turn.
Items inside the page stay in ascending ``seq`` order.
"""
data: list[ConversationItem]
has_more: bool
first_seq: int | None
last_seq: int | None
@dataclass
class SessionView:
"""Bounded read model returned by Builder session-facing routes.
Conversation history deliberately lives behind ``ConversationPage``. This
object is safe to send at command start/end without payload growth as a
session gets older.
"""
session_id: str
app_id: str
version: int
state: str
canvas_read_only: bool
run_status: RunStatus
interrupted: bool
conversation_last_seq: int
entry_mode: EntryMode = EntryMode.FIX
phase: Phase = Phase.UNDERSTAND
# DEPRECATED until the web client reads ``decision``: the same choice, in
# the standalone-button shape.
actions: list[Action] = field(default_factory=list)
decision: Decision | None = None
active_interaction: ActiveInteraction | None = None
checkpoint: CheckpointRef | None = None
recovery: RecoveryRef | None = None
model: SessionModel | None = None
app_revision: AppRevision | None = None
@dataclass
class ConflictPolicyOption:
"""One selectable conflict-resolution policy in a ``resource_select`` card."""
id: str
label: str
recommended: bool = False
@dataclass
class PreflightIssue:
"""One checklist finding in a ``preflight_context`` card.
``kind`` in connection|variable|required_config|availability.
"""
node_id: str
label: str
kind: str
ExecutionActivityState = Literal["active", "done", "failed", "stopped"]
ExecutionActivityKind = Literal["stage", "node"]
ExecutionProgressStatus = Literal["running", "completed", "error", "stopped"]
@dataclass
class ExecutionActivity:
"""One observable action that has started during a Builder operation.
Planned future work is intentionally absent. Node activities use
``parent_id`` to sit under the stage that owns the workflow run.
"""
id: str
label: str
state: ExecutionActivityState
kind: ExecutionActivityKind = "stage"
parent_id: str | None = None
@dataclass
class ExecutionProgress:
"""A snapshot containing only execution activities observed so far."""
status: ExecutionProgressStatus
activities: list[ExecutionActivity] = field(default_factory=list)
@dataclass
class TestStat:
"""One stat tile in a ``test_result`` card."""
# Not a pytest test class; ``__test__`` (unannotated, so not a dataclass
# field) tells pytest's Test*-name collector to skip it.
__test__ = False
value: str
label: str
@dataclass
class SummaryRow:
"""One row of a ``completion``-variant ``summary`` card."""
label: str
value: str
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Cards (spec §4.3). Each subclasses ``_Card``: ``kind`` is a ``ClassVar``
# discriminant (not a dataclass field), so ``dataclasses.asdict(card)`` is
# exactly the card's wire ``payload`` -- no redundant ``kind`` inside it.
# ``to_item`` wraps the payload into the shipped ``ConversationItem``
# envelope (§4.1): ``{seq, kind, payload, at_version}``.
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
@dataclass
class _Card:
kind: ClassVar[CardKind]
def to_item(self, seq: int, at_version: int) -> ConversationItem:
return ConversationItem(seq=seq, kind=str(self.kind), payload=asdict(self), at_version=at_version)
@dataclass
class UserItem(_Card):
"""Right-aligned bubble: raw user text."""
kind: ClassVar[CardKind] = CardKind.USER
text: str
turn_id: str
@dataclass
class DecisionItem(_Card):
"""Right-aligned bubble: a committed-choice summary."""
kind: ClassVar[CardKind] = CardKind.DECISION
text: str
@dataclass
class NoticeItem(_Card):
"""A neutral/informational system notice."""
kind: ClassVar[CardKind] = CardKind.NOTICE
text: str
tone: str = "neutral"
@dataclass
class RunContextCard(_Card):
"""Fix-run injected context (spec §4.3). ``trace_ref`` is redacted."""
kind: ClassVar[CardKind] = CardKind.RUN_CONTEXT
run_id: str
title: str
error_code: str
message: str
trace_ref: str = ""
@dataclass
class PreflightContextCard(_Card):
"""Checklist-fix injected context (spec §4.3)."""
kind: ClassVar[CardKind] = CardKind.PREFLIGHT_CONTEXT
node_count: int
issue_count: int
issues: list[PreflightIssue] = field(default_factory=list)
@dataclass
class AssistantTurnItem(_Card):
"""The streamable unit (spec §4.2). ``stage_id`` is the PcState this
turn ran in; ``cards`` lists which cards (in order) this turn attaches.
``card_state`` is ``None`` or ``"invalidated"`` (frozen after task exit).
"""
kind: ClassVar[CardKind] = CardKind.ASSISTANT_TURN
turn_id: str
stage_id: str
execution: ExecutionProgress
reasoning_text: str | None = None
reply_text: str | None = None
cards: list[str] = field(default_factory=list)
card_state: str | None = None
@dataclass
class PlanCard(_Card):
"""Versioned plan (spec §4.3). ``items`` are ordered, human-readable
steps. Build emits v1/v2/v2.x; Edit emits a single change plan.
"""
kind: ClassVar[CardKind] = CardKind.PLAN
title: str
version_tag: str
items: list[str] = field(default_factory=list)
subtitle: str | None = None
@dataclass
class FormCard(_Card):
"""Editable, re-submittable input card. ``variant`` in
build_requirements|edit_rules|testdata.
"""
kind: ClassVar[CardKind] = CardKind.FORM
variant: str
fields: list[FormField] = field(default_factory=list)
values: dict = field(default_factory=dict)
frozen: bool = False
@dataclass
class ChallengeCard(_Card):
"""High-impact-rule confirmation, distinct from a plain question."""
kind: ClassVar[CardKind] = CardKind.CHALLENGE
title: str
body: str
tone: str = "warning"
@dataclass
class ResourceSelectCard(_Card):
"""Resource discovery: multi-select ``recommended`` resources +
single-select ``conflict_policy_options``.
"""
kind: ClassVar[CardKind] = CardKind.RESOURCE_SELECT
recommended: list[ResourceOption] = field(default_factory=list)
conflict_policy_options: list[ConflictPolicyOption] = field(default_factory=list)
@dataclass
class CheckpointCard(_Card):
"""Restore point, backed by create-checkpoint/revert-checkpoint canvas
events. Restoring invalidates prior approvals.
"""
kind: ClassVar[CardKind] = CardKind.CHECKPOINT
checkpoint_id: str
label: str
created_at: str
@dataclass
class ChangeSetCard(_Card):
"""Read-only change summary. ``scope`` in annotation|configuration|structure."""
kind: ClassVar[CardKind] = CardKind.CHANGE_SET
count: int
changes: list[str]
scope: str
nodes: list[ChangedNode] = field(default_factory=list)
@dataclass
class TestResultCard(_Card):
"""Structured test/verify result. ``tone`` in success|error."""
# Not a pytest test class; ``__test__`` (unannotated, so not a dataclass
# field) tells pytest's Test*-name collector to skip it.
__test__ = False
kind: ClassVar[CardKind] = CardKind.TEST_RESULT
title: str
subtitle: str
tone: str
stats: list[TestStat] = field(default_factory=list)
run_ids: list[str] = field(default_factory=list)
@dataclass
class ErrorCard(_Card):
"""A found/fixed problem."""
kind: ClassVar[CardKind] = CardKind.ERROR
title: str
body: str
tone: str = "danger"
node_id: str | None = None
# Machine-readable failure breadcrumbs (server timestamp + generator codes /
# node ids). Not rendered: it rides along in the item payload so the exported
# debug log retains what would otherwise only exist in a pod log.
diagnostics: list[dict[str, Any]] = field(default_factory=list)
@dataclass
class SummaryCard(_Card):
"""Polymorphic by phase. ``variant`` in context|review|completion --
``items`` is used for context/review, ``rows`` for completion.
"""
kind: ClassVar[CardKind] = CardKind.SUMMARY
variant: str
title: str | None = None
items: list[str] = field(default_factory=list)
rows: list[SummaryRow] = field(default_factory=list)
@dataclass
class PublishCard(_Card):
"""Publish confirmation. Build -> v1.0, Edit -> v2.4-style bump, Fix ->
patch bump.
"""
kind: ClassVar[CardKind] = CardKind.PUBLISH
version: str
badge: str = "live"
@dataclass
class BuildLearningCard(_Card):
"""Post-build "sink this experience into System Skills?" card.
Deferred -- contract-only for now. ``policy`` is a
``SkillLearningPolicy`` value; ``state`` in pending|accepted|skipped.
"""
kind: ClassVar[CardKind] = CardKind.BUILD_LEARNING
policy: str
state: str
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Typed submit payloads (spec §5, ``SubmitPayloadKind``). Plain dataclasses
# -- no ``kind`` discriminant, no ``to_item``: these are POSTed by the FE as
# ``Action.payload``, never persisted as conversation items.
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
@dataclass
class GoalPayload:
text: str
@dataclass
class EditGoalPayload:
text: str
@dataclass
class RequirementsPayload:
report_types: str
audience: str
currency: str
metrics: str
output: str
prefer_audited: bool = False
@dataclass
class EditRulesPayload:
risk_threshold: str
review_team: str
timeout_behavior: str
preserve_summary: bool = False
@dataclass
class ResourcesPayload:
conflict_policy: str
resource_ids: list[str] = field(default_factory=list)
@dataclass
class RunContextPayload:
run_id: str
node_name: str
error_code: str
@dataclass
class CheckpointPayload:
checkpoint_id: str
@dataclass
class TestPayload:
# Not a pytest test class; ``__test__`` (unannotated, so not a dataclass
# field) tells pytest's Test*-name collector to skip it.
__test__ = False
run_ids: list[str] = field(default_factory=list)
@dataclass
class PublishPayload:
version: str
@dataclass
class TestdataPayload:
"""``mode`` in upload|self_test|mock."""
mode: str
inputs: dict | None = None
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# SSE payloads. ``_SseEventData`` is the shared wire-payload marker. Each payload
# declares its envelope event name as the ``sse_event`` ClassVar. Bus-level
# ``kind`` remains on payloads while the HTTP transport wraps each value in a
# generated ``{ event, data }`` response envelope.
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
class _SseEventData:
sse_event: ClassVar[str]
@dataclass
class CommandStartedEventData(SessionView, _SseEventData):
"""Bounded command/reconnect handshake; never contains conversation history."""
sse_event: ClassVar[str] = "command_started"
kind: Literal["command_started"] = "command_started"
@dataclass
class NodeEventData(_SseEventData):
sse_event: ClassVar[str] = "node"
session_id: str
operation_id: str
stage_id: str
at_version: int
revision: int
node_id: str
title: str
status: str
error: str
kind: Literal["node"] = "node"
@dataclass
class CanvasEdge:
source: str
target: str
@dataclass
class CanvasEventData(_SseEventData):
sse_event: ClassVar[str] = "canvas"
session_id: str
operation_id: str
stage_id: str
at_version: int
revision: int
event: CanvasEvent
kind: Literal["canvas"] = "canvas"
node_id: str | None = None
edge: CanvasEdge | None = None
@dataclass
class AgentMessageEventData(_SseEventData):
"""One incremental assistant-text chunk for an in-flight chat turn.
``answer`` follows the existing Dify ``agent_message`` convention: it is
a delta, not the accumulated answer. ``seq``/``at_version`` identify the
durable assistant item that replaces the transient stream item when the
turn commits.
"""
sse_event: ClassVar[str] = "agent_message"
session_id: str
operation_id: str
id: str
answer: str
seq: int
at_version: int
revision: int
stage_id: str
kind: Literal["agent_message"] = "agent_message"
@dataclass
class ReasoningEventData(_SseEventData):
"""One model-provided reasoning delta for the current operation.
Reasoning is independent from curated execution progress. ``span_id``
identifies the cognitive call within an operation so clients can preserve
stable rendering while deltas arrive.
"""
sse_event: ClassVar[str] = "reasoning"
session_id: str
operation_id: str
stage_id: str
at_version: int
revision: int
span_id: str
delta: str
kind: Literal["reasoning"] = "reasoning"
@dataclass
class ProgressEventData(_SseEventData):
"""A replaceable execution snapshot for an in-flight operation.
``revision`` is monotonic within ``operation_id``. ``at_version`` points
at the next durable transition that supersedes this snapshot, allowing a
client to discard delayed progress after it has already applied a commit.
The payload contains observable actions only. Model-provided reasoning is
delivered separately through ``ReasoningEventData``.
"""
sse_event: ClassVar[str] = "progress"
session_id: str
operation_id: str
stage_id: str
at_version: int
revision: int
execution: ExecutionProgress
kind: Literal["progress"] = "progress"
@dataclass
class CommitEventData(_SseEventData):
"""One CAS-backed conversation increment emitted before terminal state."""
sse_event: ClassVar[str] = "commit"
session_id: str
operation_id: str
stage_id: str
at_version: int
version: int
state: str
settled: bool
items: list[ConversationItem]
kind: Literal["commit"] = "commit"
@dataclass
class StateEventData(SessionView, _SseEventData):
sse_event: ClassVar[str] = "state"
kind: Literal["state"] = "state"
@dataclass
class ErrorEventData(_SseEventData):
sse_event: ClassVar[str] = "error"
error: str
kind: Literal["error"] = "error"
code: str | None = None
message: str | None = None
recoverable: bool | None = None